Ebenezer – Review

Cert – 12, Run-time – 1 hour 56 minutes, Director – Ti West

Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) confronts the events of his past when three spirits challenge him to change his miserable ways over the night before Christmas.

There are two films playing out alongside each other in Ebenezer. One is Ti West’s ghost story for Christmas, the other is the Johnny Depp show. They try to co-exist, and at times do, but there’s a tendency to clash simply due to the different ones with which they both strike.

Having completed his X trilogy, West turns to bringing out the haunting elements of Charles Dickens’ annually retold Christmas tale. And he manages to bring out some eerie moments with focus on the ghostly aspects as Scrooge (Depp) is followed by translucent figures between interactions with the three spirits coming to him in order to change his miserly ways. Trammell Tillman’s Ghost Of Christmas Present is a much less jovial figure than usual, he’s played in as Shakespearean a manner as Ian McKellen brings to his Jacob Marley.

Ebenezer holds a handful of different acting styles, from the aforementioned to Sam Claflin’s Fred stemming from someone who has religiously watched The Muppets take multiple times each festive season, as has Rupert Grint in the opening stages of his warm and fatherly Bob Cratchit. The Muppets understood that Scrooge is not a character made for laughs, there can be humour around him but we’re not meant to get direct amusement from the spirit of ‘bah, humbug!’ Yet, after initially playing the character up with angles and potential hopes of humour Depp simply overacts Scrooge for much of the first half of the film.


Where the performance starts to even out is in the moments that give space to what I feel a number of adaptations of A Christmas Carol are very quick to get to. Often Scrooge feels as if halfway through his meeting with the Ghost Of Christmas Present he snaps and changes his ways, becomes immediately kinder, more emotional and redemptive. Depp manages to prolong that process and actually show a work towards redemption in the shifts in the character throughout the night – especially in conversations with Tillman who commands the screen during his time. In this light the events of Christmas Day are also shown in more light, and while the lead’s overacting turns its head again there’s a likable nature to the time given to his changed ways.

We see occasional details that feel placed to play into the romantic emotions of a modern Hollywood take, even amongst the Victorian setting, largely revolving around Scrooge’s relationship with Belle (Ellie Bamber), with young Scrooge played by Arthur Conti. And there are details that the film has sprinkled in to try and expand the story and past of the title character, which tend to backfire and have a slightly undercooked, and unnecessary feeling. And not even in regards to changing up one of the most timeless and retold stories out there, there are plenty of different takes that bring in new ideas out there, but here the scattering of new details just don’t seem to click or work.

There’s a good deal of Ebenezer that sometimes struggles to get a response, or just simply properly click. And some of that comes down to the overacting of the lead who particularly in the first half has the energy of a child delivering their one line in a nativity play. When more restrained and leaning into the self-confrontation of the role there’s a film that flows better, and has more of a dramatic effect, as the performance works more in line with the tone and style of the kind of film that West appears to be trying to make.

In longer views of Scrooge’s change Ebenezer succeeds where other versions of A Christmas Carol miss out, it’s just a shame that Depp’s overacting sometimes overshadows the eerie ghost story that’s elsewhere.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Leave a Reply