Cert – 12, Run-time – 1 hour 41 minutes, Director – Cathryn Michon
Basset hound Winstead (Thomas Hayden Church) observes his distant family growing closer when one (Kathleen Rose Perkins) is put into a coma just before Christmas.
If you like Hallmark movies but don’t want to admit to watching them, A Dog’s Perfect Christmas may be your scapegoat. It has all the cliches, tones and artificial festivity without the production company’s name or banner. Instead, Netflix stumps up the money for this latest entry in the Dog’s Purpose franchise – directed by previous entries’ screenwriter Cathryn Michon, with an early-November Christmas flick almost perfectly designed for their platform.
Dennis Quaid (another returning face from previous films, although this time as a different character) plays Sander, he’s spent months isolating himself after the loss of his wife. His beard has slightly grown, he wears a dressing gown and whilst looking like a last-minute Halloween costume that’s meant to be The Dude everyone in town thinks he looks homeless. He’s barely left the house, even not spending much time with faithful bassett hound Winstead (Thomas Hayden Church).
It’s Winstead who guides us through the lives of Sander and his family. His narration implies a film for younger viewers, or perhaps just the simple ways in which a dog might think, it could easily seem just basic, not the best writing, but the film manages to just about get away with it – if with a couple of bruises. Whether this is down to the simple fact of: Dog, or Hayden Church’s voice work I genuinely can’t say, although I’d lean more to the former with assistance from the latter. Winstead is then highlight of the film, and compensates for the generic nature of the surroundings as Sander has to get closer to his family, who he’s somewhat pushed away, when daughter-in-law Juliana (Kathleen Rose Perkins), who largely keeps the house running, falls ill and is put into a coma just before the holidays.

Meanwhile son Hunter (Milo Ventimiglia), who Juliana may be close to divorcing, is struggling to get his ideas heard at work, grandaughter Ello (Brooke Lena Johnson) feels almost invisible, but also doesn’t want attention and may also be developing a crush and before you can shout bingo Sander may also find sparks flying with Mary Steenburgen’s Claire. All the joys amongst the fear and sadness brought about by a hospitalised family member at this time of year. And it’s treated as you might expect; without very much charm and not quite enough sweetness to be called saccharine.
Winstead helps us see things through, and Quaid gives a likable performance alongside Johnson; the pair make a good duo who are unfortunately not very often glimpsed together, or just given something strong enough to work with. The story could easily revolve around just them for the most part, but everyone’s struggles are kept largely separate, probably to emphasises everyone coming together later on. For the most part the grandfather-granddaughter pairing are given conversational scenes to establish what’s about to happen in the next couple of scenes, while Winstead tells us what’s happening in that very moment by describing the sad or happy expressions on the faces that we can see in front of us.
But the dog, eventually dogs when corgi puppy Ruby is introduced, tries to be our biggest connection, and usually manages to bring a smile as he focuses on food dropping on the floor amidst a serious family conversation. The rest of the film can’t quite muster the same levels of excitement, or get the audience to feel the same concern for the family either. Generally this apparently perfect Christmas plods along with one or two likable details, but not enough festive goodwill to see its Hallmark-style cliches through.
While the titular dog helps, the biggest draw of Quaid and Johnson’s likable pairing is never allowed anything more than direct conversations explaining what’s happening in that moment before the artificial Hallmark sweetness of A Dog’s Perfect Christmas kicks in again.